Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

You all seem to be such proficient chefs. Well here is a place to share some of that cooking knowledge. Or do you have a cooking problem? Ask away. Jams and chutneys go here too.
Post Reply
Tom Good
Tom Good
Posts: 62
Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:56 am
Location: Slovenia

Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

Post: # 204993Post organicsi »

Article from the Washington post website on using ice and salt in sealed plastic bags to make ice cream and sorbet without an ice cream maker!
There are some recipes too I can put those up if anyone is interested.
Gastronomer: No-machine ice cream

By Andreas Viestad
Special to The Washington Post
Tuesday, August 3, 2010; 10:33 AM

It seems as if the entire world is melting. Still, there is one summer activity that can cool things down a bit and even tease the brain into a little bit of learning, with school still weeks away.

In my family, making ice cream and sorbet in a bag is a favorite pastime. Not much can go wrong: There are no machines that need to be assembled or cleaned or that can otherwise conspire against you, no advanced technical skills to learn or preparation times to keep track of.

Fill a large sealable plastic bag with ice and salt. Fill a smaller, food-safe plastic bag with an ice cream mixture or sweetened juice. Cradle the smaller bag inside the larger one and seal. Shake for a few minutes. Eureka! You have the freshest, softest, most perfect ice cream or sorbet. And, unlike kitchen-based ice cream making, this technique is best when performed outdoors: under a tree, on the beach or while hiking far from civilization.

There is nothing novel about the method. Apart from the use of plastic, the technique has been used since at least the 13th century, when there were reports of ice cream being savored by European visitors to the Arab world, and possibly all the way back to 10th-century China, from whence a poem titled "Ode to the Ice Cheese" has led food historians to speculate on the method's earlier origins.

I like making ice cream this way because of the sheer joy of watching children control the process, from the actual freezing to the happy jostle for the last spoonful. (There is always one more spoonful to be found inside the bag.) I also like the way the treat introduces an element of learning into summertime laziness.

What are the principles at work? That is what I show my kids as they stir together ice and salt, and while we all watch the magic that ensues. I know the basics, but when I have to explain it, I reconnect to a bit of everyday knowledge.

When you have a mixture of ice and water, such as a glass of water with lots of ice cubes, the two find equilibrium and the temperature stabilizes at the freezing point, or melting point, of 32 degrees Fahrenheit. There will be some melting of the ice, and at the same time there will be some freezing of the water. But it does not all suddenly freeze or melt. If the surrounding area is warm, there will be some net melting. But the process is relatively slow.

Water needs a lot of persuading to pass from one phase to another. When water reaches the boiling point, it starts to turn into gas. But as we all know after having boiled potatoes and pasta innumerable times, the vaporization takes time and lots of energy; after 10 or 20 minutes of vigorous boiling, water has evaporated noticeably but not dramatically.

The same applies to the processes of freezing and melting. The ice takes energy from its surroundings in order to melt. But if you place your bag of ice cream mixture inside a bag of ice, the only thing you will achieve is the same sort of equilibrium as with a glass of water and ice cubes: The ice remains as melting ice-water slush at 32 degrees, and the ice cream mixture is cooled to 32 degrees but remains in its liquid state.

Add salt to the ice, and the equilibrium is disrupted. The melting process speeds up. At the same time, salt lowers the freezing point of the water, or brine, surrounding the ice.

After a few minutes, the temperature drops 10, 20 or even as much as 32 degrees, to zero degrees (or below), depending on the amount of salt added, a phenomenon so fascinating that Daniel Fahrenheit used it as the starting point when making his temperature scale in the early 1700s.

A mixture of about 10 percent salt in water will take the freezing point to 21 degrees. The lowest possible temperature that can be achieved by this method is with 23.3 percent salt, which can lower the temperature to 6 degrees below zero; there is no need to add more than that. (Because we are not doing this in a lab, it is doubtful that we will achieve temperatures quite as low. Without making any special effort to dissolve all of the salt, I have achieved 2 degrees, and that is more than cold enough to make ice cream.)

The surprising thing about making ice cream in a bag is not just that it works but that it is a lot quicker than using an electric ice cream maker. That highlights another everyday principle, namely that liquid is a fantastically efficient conductor of temperature. If you were simply to place the bag of ice cream batter in your freezer, it could take hours to freeze in the cold air.

In addition, bag-made ice cream turns out soft and smooth, not grainy. That is because the constant movement involved in the process prevents large ice crystals from forming in the ice cream. Again, if you were to place the bag in the freezer, it would freeze into one large block. (Ice cream makers typically have a mechanical arm that stirs the batter as it chills.)

You can use any kind of salt. I prefer to use the cheapest fine-grain salt I can find. Fine salt dissolves faster and makes for the most efficient melting of the ice, which in turn lowers the temperature. Rock salt works well, too, but its rough structure can damage the plastic bags. As for the ice, I prefer crushed, because it provides more surface area and melts faster than larger ice cubes or a big lump of ice.

So, is it all about bribing kids to learn? Of course not. It is about bribing adults to learn as well. In addition to giving the kids a short chemistry and physics lesson - and all the pleasure that entails - I create a few indulgences for the adults. Adding a little alcohol to some of the sorbet mixtures, I make frozen or semi-frozen drinks for the grown-ups.

The introduction of alcohol produces some of the same effect as salt, in that it lowers the freezing point of the liquid that contains it. A mixture with 10 percent alcohol has a freezing point of 25 degrees (or lower, depending on the other components and the amount of solids in the batter), and a 20 percent solution freezes at around 15 degrees. (A mixture with more than 30 percent alcohol, which would make for a mighty strong margarita or daiquiri, will not freeze using the salt-and-ice method, and moreover is not advisable for all sorts of reasons.)

This alcohol enhancement is best done after the kids have gone to bed, but it is no less of a knowledge-enhancing process. I have found that many adults who have shown no great interest or ability in sciences take a childishly enthusiastic, albeit somewhat unwholesome, interest in the calibration of alcohol in the drinks vis a vis the composition of the ice-and-salt mixture.

"How cool is that!" they exclaim, just as the kids did a few hours earlier.
Last edited by organicsi on Mon Aug 09, 2010 9:08 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Barbara Good
Barbara Good
Posts: 174
Joined: Sun Sep 07, 2008 5:06 pm
Location: Barry, Near Carnoustie

Re: Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

Post: # 205009Post kit-e-kate »

That sounds great! Can't wait to give it a try! :icon_smile:

Barbara Good
Barbara Good
Posts: 132
Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2010 3:52 pm
latitude: 52.5
longitude: -1.9
Location: West Midlands

Re: Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

Post: # 205012Post Shirleymouse »

This sounds like a far better project for the day than clearing out all my kitchen cupboards which is what I had planned to do!

User avatar
Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
Posts: 47
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2010 9:28 pm
latitude: 40° 46' N
longitude: 111° 58' W
Location: Salt Lake City, UT USA

Re: Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

Post: # 205040Post Bikil »

Sounds like fun, and I love the science! Anything that can show real world science with yummy results is good by me!
It is a mistake to think you can solve any major problems just with potatoes.
- Douglas Adams

User avatar
A selfsufficientish Regular
A selfsufficientish Regular
Posts: 655
Joined: Tue Jul 10, 2007 7:05 pm
Location: Kent / central portugal

Re: Article on how to make Ice cream in a bag!!

Post: # 205062Post battybird »

Recipes would be great...I HAVE to try this! Was going to wait till children visitors come but ... can't! :iconbiggrin:
The cockerel makes the noise, the hen produces the goods!! anon

Post Reply