Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Apologies for the newbie question.
I'm just wondering if it's good to remove fungi from trees to prevent damage? Or do they actually help trees and the environment?
Thanks for any replies
I'm just wondering if it's good to remove fungi from trees to prevent damage? Or do they actually help trees and the environment?
Thanks for any replies
-
- margo - newbie
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 5:54 pm
- Location: Dumfries & Galloway, Scotland
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Hi 1984jay,
Without fungi we would be well over head height in plant matter that simply would not decompose without fungis help.
If a parasitic fungi is in the wild then I suggest it should be left, as this is simply nature taking its course. Unless of course it is edible!
If it is taking hold in your garden/on your property then an arborist may be the person to talk to regarding the best procedure.
Hope this helps.
Oink
Without fungi we would be well over head height in plant matter that simply would not decompose without fungis help.
If a parasitic fungi is in the wild then I suggest it should be left, as this is simply nature taking its course. Unless of course it is edible!
If it is taking hold in your garden/on your property then an arborist may be the person to talk to regarding the best procedure.
Hope this helps.
Oink
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
[Edit - not quite sure I agree now, read down]
Agreed.
Just there're some lovely (old) trees around, just thought in that regard it would be better to prevent further rot occouring
Thanks
Agreed.
Just there're some lovely (old) trees around, just thought in that regard it would be better to prevent further rot occouring
Thanks
Last edited by 1984jay on Wed Sep 17, 2014 9:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Tom Good
- Posts: 93
- Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2012 7:30 pm
- Location: Rotterdam, the Netherlands
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Even if you remove the mushroom (don't know how you call it exactly but you know what I mean), the fungus is still growing in the tree. A tree-expert will know what to do. My guess is the tree was already weak or else the fungus wouldn't have taken hold.
Roos
Roos
My blog: https://thelifeofalittlerose.wordpress.com
My dutch blog: https://hetlevenvaneenroosje.wordpress.com has the same content bu is updated sooner.
My dutch blog: https://hetlevenvaneenroosje.wordpress.com has the same content bu is updated sooner.
- Geoff Dann
- Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:43 pm
- Location: Hastings
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
If something like honey fungus is already attacking some tree, old or not, then it is probably doomed anyway. Removing the fruiting bodies will not prevent the fungus from killing the tree. It will just reduce its reproductive chances this year.1984jay wrote:Agreed.
Just there're some lovely (old) trees around, just thought in that regard it would be better to prevent further rot occouring
Thanks
You can't "cure" a tree of parasitic fungi.
- Geoff Dann
- Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:43 pm
- Location: Hastings
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Yes.littlemissrose wrote:My guess is the tree was already weak or else the fungus wouldn't have taken hold.
Roos
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Who's to say you can't "cure" a tree Geoff?
My views have quickly changed since previous posts I think. To everyone saying "The tree is doomed" I strongly disagree. If any of you know anything about trees it's that you can chop one down leaving even the smallest of tree stumps and it will still grow back..... ye of little faith.
Plants are amazing, and very robust. So to say there's "no cure" is ridiculous. No disrespect to anyone who's posted.
My views have quickly changed since previous posts I think. To everyone saying "The tree is doomed" I strongly disagree. If any of you know anything about trees it's that you can chop one down leaving even the smallest of tree stumps and it will still grow back..... ye of little faith.
Plants are amazing, and very robust. So to say there's "no cure" is ridiculous. No disrespect to anyone who's posted.
- Zech
- Site Admin
- Posts: 857
- Joined: Wed Dec 15, 2010 3:05 pm
- latitude: 52.36
- longitude: -3.84
- Location: Mid Wales
- Contact:
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
I think Geoff's comment about the tree being doomed was specific to the honey fungus (sorry if I've got that wrong, Geoff) - not all fungi are quite so aggressive. That said, whatever the species, just taking the fruiting body off the surface of the tree isn't going to make any difference, so if that's what you meant by 'removing' a parasitic fungus, then no, it's not worth it - that won't prevent further rot occurring. On the other hand, if you're talking about major tree surgery to cut out all of the fungus, then yes, that might save the tree. I'm not sure how feasible that is - as others have said, it would be worth talking to an arborist for advice on this.
---
Rachel
Take nobody's word for it, especially not mine! If I offer you an ID of something based on a photo, please treat it as a guess, and a starting point for further investigations.
My blog: http://growingthingsandmakingthings.blogspot.com/
Rachel
Take nobody's word for it, especially not mine! If I offer you an ID of something based on a photo, please treat it as a guess, and a starting point for further investigations.
My blog: http://growingthingsandmakingthings.blogspot.com/
-
- Tom Good
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2014 10:02 am
- Location: Berlin
- Contact:
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Unless it's your own tree you are growing in your garden and you are desperate to keep it, then I'd just let nature take it's course. The death of this old tree, both the process and the final result itself, is beneficial to so many different organisms, and the death of an old tree usually also causes a break in the canopy which can allow some of the younger ones to shoot up and take advantage of the real sunlight at last. As strange as it might seem, we need naturally dying trees to keep the balance right and allow wild spaces to continue to develop.
So unless it was an invasive species, I wouldn't remove parasitic fungi or anything else. I'd take the opportunity to watch as nature does it's thing!
So unless it was an invasive species, I wouldn't remove parasitic fungi or anything else. I'd take the opportunity to watch as nature does it's thing!
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Interesting view Smilesbetter :)
Sounds about right..
Although for the purpose of education it's good to know these things. Interesting to think of it that way though.
Sounds about right..
Although for the purpose of education it's good to know these things. Interesting to think of it that way though.
- Geoff Dann
- Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:43 pm
- Location: Hastings
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Yes to all of that.Zech wrote:I think Geoff's comment about the tree being doomed was specific to the honey fungus (sorry if I've got that wrong, Geoff) - not all fungi are quite so aggressive. That said, whatever the species, just taking the fruiting body off the surface of the tree isn't going to make any difference, so if that's what you meant by 'removing' a parasitic fungus, then no, it's not worth it - that won't prevent further rot occurring. On the other hand, if you're talking about major tree surgery to cut out all of the fungus, then yes, that might save the tree. I'm not sure how feasible that is - as others have said, it would be worth talking to an arborist for advice on this.
Honey Fungus is the archetypal parasitic tree fungus - it's the most (in)famous. But it is also unusual among parasites. Most parasites avoid, if they can, killing their host, because that isn't much of a long term strategy for themselves. Honey Fungus doesn't care. It's quite happy to kill the host and then go on feeding on its corpse. Eventually it runs out of food, but by then it has spread itself about so prolifically that this is a viable evolutionary strategy for this particular parasite.
- Geoff Dann
- Jerry - Bit higher than newbie
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:43 pm
- Location: Hastings
Re: Should you remove parasitic Fungi
Yes. People associate fungi with death, but this is backwards. Fungi are the agents of new life - they should be associated with rebirth, not death! Without them we'd be up to our necks in organic rubbish.Smilesbetter wrote:Unless it's your own tree you are growing in your garden and you are desperate to keep it, then I'd just let nature take it's course. The death of this old tree, both the process and the final result itself, is beneficial to so many different organisms, and the death of an old tree usually also causes a break in the canopy which can allow some of the younger ones to shoot up and take advantage of the real sunlight at last. As strange as it might seem, we need naturally dying trees to keep the balance right and allow wild spaces to continue to develop.
So unless it was an invasive species, I wouldn't remove parasitic fungi or anything else. I'd take the opportunity to watch as nature does it's thing!